Welcome to Doomsday Scenario, my regular column on national security, geopolitics, history, and—unfortunately—the fight for democracy in the Trump era. I hope if you’re coming to this online, you’ll consider subscribing right here. It’s easy—and free:

We have lived through a weird moment in US politics over the last decade, as Donald Trump has built two successful presidential campaigns on the premise that he will make America great “again,” an explicit reference to the idea that America’s greatest days are somehow behind us. The phrase itself is hardly new — Ronald Reagan ran in 1980 on “Let’s Make America Great Again” — and it’s clear that Trump’s movement means his slogan in a specific sense, a return to some invented nostalgic era circa the 1950s when white Christian men were on top in American society.

But beyond the racist and nativist undertones, Trump’s electioneering promise also gets the American Dream entirely wrong. The whole point of the American Experiment is that our country’s best days are supposed to be ahead of us.

From the very first days of our nation’s history, we set out to make tomorrow better than today. While we rightly have celebrated this year the triumphs of Philadelphia and the nation’s Founding in 1776, much of the hard work of realizing the dream of a multi-racial, multi-gender, multi-faith, pluralistic democracy was left for others to sort out. That’s the story that I’ve tried to tell in my new book, AMERICA IN 25 REVOLUTIONS. It is a story of hope, passion, courage, and how generation after generation of Americans refused to accept the status quo and instead wrote themselves into the American story — often only after crusades for change that lasted for years, decades, and even generations beyond them.

In fact, the first chapter — the first revolution! — begins even before the Constitution was ratified, when the Founders set about on the process of amending it and creating what we now call the Bill of Rights. The Founders understood they weren’t going to get everything right the first time — and so they gave us the mechanisms to ensure that the next revolution didn’t have to be an armed rebellion. That spirit proved the enduring genius of the Founders’ original vision — each subsequent generation was able to expand it and move the nation closer to their still-never-achieved ideal of a country where all considered equal.

That original idea set off centuries of ripples and repercussions that the Founders never could have imagined, as people — including many those white property-owning Christian male Founders didn’t even consider “citizens” at the time, either legally or morally — seized their idea and made it their own. We forget just how small their original vision was of who “counted” as an American. Out of a national population of just about four million (including about 700,000 enslaved people), only around 50,000 white men voted in the 1789 election in which the electoral college unanimously selected Washington as president. The second revolution I cover is the remarkable story of how voting rights were opened up to white men who didn’t own property and how we broke with our European roots and enabled an incredible revolution in social and geographic mobility — a first step toward a more egalitarian country.

That promise of a better tomorrow became the animating principle of our country.

Today, much of our country would astound the Founders. That’s a good thing. In fact, it’s perhaps the best thing about our country.

Speaking at Howard University in 2016, President Obama said, “If you had to choose one moment in history in which you could be born, and you didn’t know ahead of time who you were going to be—what nationality, what gender, what race, whether you’d be rich or poor, gay or straight, what faith you’d be born into—you wouldn’t choose 100 years ago. You wouldn’t choose the fifties, or the sixties, or the seventies. You’d choose right now.”

Obama’s message in 2016 was important then because we forget today how American life was much worse, for many people, not all that long ago.

President Obama speaks at that 148th Howard University commencement ceremony in 2016.
(Photo By Al Drago/CQ Roll Call)

So much of our progress toward a true multi-racial, multi-gender, multi-faith pluralistic society is remarkably new. The last quotas for Jewish students in the Ivy Leagues only fell in the 1960s; Americans had walked on the moon before the first class of Yale students chosen entirely on “merit” graduated. Muscular civil rights and voting rights legislation only delivered on the promises of Reconstruction in the mid-1960s. Women couldn’t open checking accounts or have credit cards without their husband’s permission until 1974. People with disabilities weren’t guaranteed access to public transit, businesses, or even reasonable accommodations at work until the 1990s. Homosexuals were officially considered by psychiatry to be mentally ill into the 1970s, couldn’t serve openly in the military until 2011, and couldn’t marry, nationwide, until 2015.

Unfortunately, as it has turned out, Obama’s message also marked a turning point for the country — he uttered it at the last moment it was true. Donald Trump, campaigning on a promise to return America to “greatness,” has ushered in an era that actually is unique in American history: A systematic period of retrenchment and a broad rollback of human rights and civil rights that collectively now means that if you followed Obama’s premise and had to choose a moment to live as an American of unpredictable nationality, gender, race, class, faith, or sexual orientation, you would — for the first time in American history — choose a date firmly in the past.

If you had no idea whose life you would be living, you would choose to live in 2016 America, not today.

That is an astounding statement — and I believe it is unique across American history.

That’s not to say that progress is always forward, nor that America has not experienced periods of retrenchment before. We have had dark chapters—sometimes long dark chapters.

Progress of freedom and equality in the US has rarely been straight and linear; we have suffered periods where we’ve seen rights rollbacked before. A century of Jim Crow passed before muscular civil rights and voting rights legislation delivered on the forgotten promises of Reconstruction. (The erosion of those voting rights actually began in 2013, even before Obama spoke at Howard University.) Property-owning women in New Jersey were allowed to vote until 1807, before losing the franchise for nearly a century. Abortion was largely legal and unpoliced across much of the 19th century. Nativism took off in the 1920s and, among other consequences, began that era of quotas of Jewish students at Ivy League universities that continued for decades.

But we’ve never as a country seen as broad a rollback of so many rights on so many fronts as we have through the combination of recent Supreme Court rulings, state-level legislation and executive orders, and the actions of the Trump administration. We’ve never seen public health protections rolled back — many of them long fought for and achieved only at great cost and effort — in the way that they have been by the current administration.

Life today is substantially less free, equal, and just, and more uncertain for tens of millions of Americans than it was in 2016.

Women across more than a dozen states have lost access to safe abortions. Transgender military personnel have been forced out of the service just years after they were allowed to serve openly for the first time. Legal immigrants have been persecuted and even seen their long-assumed right to free-speech curtailed, and the end of protections for asylum seekers, including those who have lived here for years, threatens thousands with a dark future. Racial protections around Black voting and representations have been overturned. Trump has limited, curtailed, or shut down civil rights enforcement across the government, from the Justice Department to the Department of Education—enforcement that ensures not just racial and gender protections but also those for students with disabilities. At the Pentagon, Pete Hegseth has removed numerous women and minorities from top leadership positions and blocked the promotion of even more, just at the moment when the military’s upper ranks were beginning to reflect the country’s natural diversity — fulfilling a destiny begun by Harry Truman’s desegregation of the military after World War II.

The good news is that from what we can see so far Americans realize this, realize how fundamentally un-American it is, and don’t like it. This month’s midterms were a broad repudiation of Trump’s vision and agenda — and it was the stunning turnout among Blacks, in places like Mississippi and Georgia, and Hispanics, in places like Texas, who chose a different path for us over the coming years. Populations that had been systemically excluded from voting by the GOP in recent years — and even longer, in some cases, decades and centuries — rose up and in state after state rejected the status quo.

Now, as the country weighs that path ahead after the midterms, and a host of new leaders at the local, state, and national level transition from campaigning to governing, the challenge is clear: The country must actually focus on making America at least as great as it was in 2016 — and then move forward, again, toward a more just, equal, and fair country. There’s enormous potential in the years ahead to move these goals forward at the state level, even if progress is stymied at the federal level.

Indeed, one of the things that stood out as I worked on AMERICA IN 25 REVOLUTIONS was realizing how much the grand sweep of American history offers much reason for hope and optimism: Despite regular setbacks and periods of retrenchment, and despite the fact that 250 years on, we are still far as a nation from the true ideal of the Founders’ vision, each generation has, in its own way, brought us closer to that ideal.

Opportunities for change — big, structural change — are few, and they are often narrow and short. We must seize them when they come.

Today it is up to a new generation of leaders in state houses and on Capitol Hill — as I wrote in the wake of the election, the most diverse set of leaders our country has ever had — to both restore the sense of progress and, in their own ways, take up the mantle of the Founders for generations ahead.

We each, if we choose to be, can be a “Founder” for tomorrow.

GMG

PS: If you’ve found this useful, I hope you’ll consider subscribing and sharing this newsletter with a few friends: